Originally posted by plop101:
How many museum or bank security guards run around with VRF Gauss guns.
I saw a Wackenhut security guard unloading an ATM the other day. He was wearing a revolver and there was a 12-gauge in the cab of his armored car. Canada is TL 6/7 and LL 8/9 so this might represent a typical opponent for your psionic swashbuckler. His lightsabre would not defend very well against 00 buckshot from a 12-guage shotgun especially at anything longer than lightsabre range. If I empty a 15 round clip "SAS-style", from a 9mm pistol, or even all 6 rounds from a revolver, are you telling me that Luke Skywalker is going to parry and dodge all of those bullets, a la The Matrix? What if both guards open up simultaneously? I've never seen that in any of the Star Wars movies.
Star Wars energy weapons have ridiculously low rates of fire and, if the movies are any indication, must be abysmally inaccurate. I mean, have you ever seen a StormTrooper actually hit what he aims at?
In Traveller, slug throwers rule, and a lightsabre would be next to usless against them.
How many police patrols can call in ortillery? The light sabre, or for that matter any blade or melee weapon, fancy or not, is going to be used in those particular close combat situations where things like rapid pulse fusion guns are not immediatly available.
Toronto cops carry Glock semi-autos. My understanding is these pistols have 15 round clips. Most patrol cars also have a 12-guage shotgun. We haven't even called in the Tactical Squad and the cops already have plenty of firepower to deal with any lightsabre wielder.
Besides, any world which would restrict concealed handguns will definitely restrict a frickin laser/plasma/force sword capable of cutting through superdense (see Phantom Menace), unless that society endorses some bizarre "code duello", in which case all bets are off. Any world which would allow a lightsabre would presumably at least allow concealed handguns. Barring total surprise, I'll put my money on the handgun.
Something handy to sneak up on the guard and dispatch him, quickly. The light sabre has its disadvantages [bright, makes some noise, probably expensive] but the ability to slice through things (especially bulkheads) would be very nice.
See above.
Your standard martial arts type person with a katana probably wouldn't survive an ortillery strike either. But would you really want to fight him in a back alley way?
Well, Joe Katana better run faster than me. And he'd better avoid slipping on the trail of excrement that I leave as I run away screaming. But if you're talking about my character: why is he going into an alley alone and unarmed, anyway?
Again, unless we're talking about a world whose law level is interpreted as expressly forbidding slug throwers but expressly permitting--nay encouraging--carrying blade weapons, this is a straw man argument. If I know that guys are lurking in alleys with swords, I'm not going into an alley alone or unarmed. Joe Katana will have to be very stealthy or very clever to get more than one swipe at me before my buddies gun him down.
Especially without your combat armor and your FGMP-15 because your on a law level 7 world. Something to contemplate...
I'll repeat myself: no LL 7+ world is going to allow private citizens to walk around with a weapon that could cut a G-Carrier in half. I don't get my gauss SMG, you don't get your lightsabre. If you're concealing your weapon and carrying it illegally, how do you know that I don't have something in my coat as well?
And if I'm knocking out a museum guard, why not use a subsonic tranq round from a body pistol?
I don't think that Star Wars and Traveller dovetail very well, probably because George Lucas never played Striker. The lightsabre is a cinematic weapon which would be completely useless against TL 6/7 auto or semi-auto firearms. Besides, once people know you have one, they're going to do their best to drop you before you get close enough to use it.
The usual caveats apply, however: it's YTU, so "do what thou wilt" shall be the whole of the law.