Timerover51
SOC-14 5K
Reasonable. In that case, I suppose Timerover51's comments have less value than I thought.
I will refrain from making any more.
Reasonable. In that case, I suppose Timerover51's comments have less value than I thought.
2. I put them in a survival situation where they started with no resources to rely on, other than their wits and their characters' skillsets. We got to test out several angles of Traveller5's task system (it worked well).
I will refrain from making any more.
I disagree that this guy is a hazard... he's not much more powerful than any other retired general officer, and they are, generally powerless. They have influence, being well connected, but not power. Power is bad, but influence merely changes the way the game plays a little.
I would generally agree, NPI, but with the caveat that a retired general can become powerful (e.g.: Washington, Grant, Ike, Pershing), though many do not (e.g.: MacArthur, Lee, Scott, Bradley, Nimitz). This power will typically be political (first three), but may be financial (Pershing, and many other less notables). It is possible that such financial may become military in an OTU setting. But it is not automatic; the retired general's fame gives him a seat at the high stakes table, where he may win, lose, or just choose to cash in and go fishing. He can win power, only if he plays his cards right.
AMEN!!!
I know a multiple Masters Degree holder who is functionally semi-literate (Reading level below grade 8). I've known several bachelor's degree holders whose IQ was below 100.
And, there was an interesting study of the average IQ's by major at several big name universities... and while it showed the average for incoming freshmen was about 110, and graduates was around 125, incoming freshman was very long-tailed, while graduates was much sharper drop off on the low end. It had some graduates all the way down to IQ's in the high 80's... (Sadly, Ed majors averaged lower amongst graduates than incoming freshmen... Ed programs can be really annoying to the intellectually gifted.)
In this way a powerful corporate character (e.g. a MgT high rank Citizen:Corporate character a Merchant Prince megacorp O7 (Line Comodore) or a Noble character that promotes several times) may likely hold a fair amount of power (think on Sergei hault Overlines).
Not only high level military character may have those gaming problems derived from too powerful a character, the referee must either adapt the adventures to them or outright forbide them (e.g. by limiting the number of terms allowed in CharGen).
First, when I am GM, I only allow characters that have actually retired from their service (or been kicked out or such). And IMTU, many nobles do not choose to serve the government, and hence have an influential name and manners, but they don't have power.
Seriously, as GM I feel I have the right to veto any character I feel uncomfortable about. I would probably veto any character that would be recognized (in a positive way) across the entire Imperium and beyond.
As to a retired general, well, if he won the battle of Whatsit against the Vargr, set much of the game in the Vargr extents. Perhaps even bordering on the area where he killed so many of their people...
On the other hand, a marine general with a chestful of medals would probably not be remembered too long except by military historians. Yes, if he proved his identity, he might get some unofficial help if it didn't cost anything (he might get to ride with the marines to another planet, but they wouldn't go out of their way for him, *except* for a very few select people). I would also give him more enemies and rivals as he has close friends. You don't get to be that high up without making enemies.
Perhaps a decision to send one unit into combat over another ended up getting somebody's wife/husband/brother killed? Heck, on most of the battles that made him famous, there had to be other officers that *could* have been chosen, and some of them will remember him and how they were passed over. There may be a price on his head from the other side...
And just remember that with great fame comes great nutcases.
What I tried to show is that the problem is not only if the character is a former high rank militry, but other careers may lead to a similar problem, if you let the players take too many terms on them (another example will be a rank 5+ performer in MgT entertainer career, as that means a famous performer whose ans will surely be annoyingly "helpful" to the group...)