Peter Newman
SOC-12
Canon tells us that the Ancients shattered planets in the Final War. It does not say that all such shattering was done by weapons. What if the Ancients shattered some planets just to make them easier to mine?
Just because you can transform elements does not mean that it might not be more efficient (I'd say cheaper but I doubt the Ancients had a market economy) to simply mine them. Since heavy elements tend to sink to planetary cores it may be easier to crack the planet for easy access. At Ancient tech levels you probably can mine planetary cores but it may not be as easy as just cracking the planet.
Thoughts?
Just because you can transform elements does not mean that it might not be more efficient (I'd say cheaper but I doubt the Ancients had a market economy) to simply mine them. Since heavy elements tend to sink to planetary cores it may be easier to crack the planet for easy access. At Ancient tech levels you probably can mine planetary cores but it may not be as easy as just cracking the planet.
Thoughts?