• Welcome to the new COTI server. We've moved the Citizens to a new server. Please let us know in the COTI Website issue forum if you find any problems.

Library Data Submissions

Spinward Scout

SOC-14 5K
Baron
Hey Hunter!

I was just wondering what was finally said and done about Library Data submissions. What are the benefits (besides helping out) to submitting entries? Rules, regulations, quirks, etc... How do you go about asking to have a correction made? And who do you talk to?

Thanks!

Scout
 
As an "Imperial Librarian" I suppose I'm in as good a position as anybody to answer these.

What are the benefits (besides helping out) to submitting entries? As of now, nothing. But keep in mind the more entries we get the better the database becomes, and the more useful a resource it will be for everybody. Note also that except for the extra-special title under my name I'm not getting anything out of this either...

Rules, regulations, quirks, etc... There's nothing specific, and the other two Librarians (Hunter and Hans Rancke-Madsen) might have different standards, but my general guidelines are: a) transcribe existing LD before creating new entries -- existing LD just needs to have its source verified, whereas new LD requires a judgment call and therefore will probably sit in the queue for awhile; b) stick as close as possible to the original entry (correct spelling or grammar or obvious mistakes, and change references to 'this year' to a year number, and similar minor changes, but don't rewrite the entry or add details specific to YTU); c) the LD should read like an in-milieu encyclopedia, so avoid rules info, references to players, and anything else out-of-milieu -- exception: if the entry includes 'secrets' or spoilers for an adventure you can include a 'Referee Only' or 'Spoiler Alert' tag; d) my personal order of preference for LD -- 1) GDW CT products, 2) T20 products, 3) FASA & Gamelords CT products, 4) GDW MT products, 5) T4 products, GT products, & TNE products, 6) other (non-DGP) 'Approved' licensees. Although I haven't been specifically instructed to do so by Hunter, I'm respecting DGP's status as 'Forbidden Canon,' so any LD found ONLY in DGP products won't be added to the database.

How do you go about asking to have a correction made? And who do you talk to?
You can talk to me, here or by mail at foster1941 at yahoo dot com. What corrections do you want made?
 
Esteemed Imperial Librarian Foster,

Actually the correction I wanted to ask about was I noticed that the link for Express Boat goes to Boat, and not to the Express Boat entry. Was wondering if that needed to be changed or if that's what was intended. Thanks for all the info. I'll get typing away!

Later,

Scout
 
Ah yes, the buggy cross-references, I'd forgotten about them. We don't type the cross-references in by hand, they're created by an automated algorithm that's not too smart. This was discussed a while ago but the conclusion reached was that 1) fixing the matching algorithm would require too much effort, and 2) buggy cross-references are more useful than no cross-references at all, so we let it stand. Perhaps someday Hunter will upgrade the program, but I wouldn't hold my breath (I'm sure he has literally hundreds of more pressing priorities -- the whole reason he appointed Hans and me to be Librarians in the first place was so he wouldn't have to bother with it anymore).
 
Back
Top