<BLOCKQUOTE>quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by Kentares:
Really !?!? I found it a excellent idea (this is a game not real world and from what I know from Traveller it is quite acceptable).
Why they find the idea of Virus idiotic ?
How would those who didnt like the Virus idea propose to change the story ?
(like I wrote in another post if they didnt do that I would never got into Traveller at the time).
<HR></BLOCKQUOTE>
Why?
1) hardware independant code (Meaning either virtual machine executeable, or multi-kernel)
2) reliant upon an almost unknown trivial bit of CT canon, plus an apparently unpublished switch to a new trandpoder system based upon that trivial bit of canon.
3) The ability to remote rewrite any computer system with telecom (Sorry, but this is the biggest cause of incredulity for me and most of my friends... and is why we decded virus MUST BE psionic.)
4) encapsulation into small devices (The Egg stage).
5) Virus was an excuse to "Wipe the slate clean" according to LKW. MWM said similar. Some of us didn't want a "Clean Slate"; Hard times was enough of a wipe.
6) The rules material contradicted the color text in many places by many persons opinions, including my own, WRT virus.
How would I see things develop sans virus:
1) Dulionor wipes out Lucan, claims the throne.
2) Strephon, real or not, gets coerced into endorsing Dulinor as the "One True Emperor", if only for the good of the Imperium. (In my campaign, this occurred due to a PC psionicist...)
3) Vland shores up, and holds out
4) The solomani retake the occupied parts of the sphere.
5)Brzrk eventually shore up, and rejoins (By force or politics, don't care)
6) Margaret holds out, and sooner or later, she'll be absorbed into one or another, or amalgamate rising pockets.
7) Norris & the DD: drop the RQS, and let it happen. The calibration points reconnect it much sooner (pre democratic reforms completion).
8) hard times: Taken for what they do, virus was unneeded, except to collapse the safes.
lots of pockets to be recaptured, or coalesce into larger polities. Realistically, any empire larger than 6 months rount trip info time is unstable; the 3I had some reaches with 6 months one way! A post shatter, short night scenario is ideal for roleplay, wargame, and novel background. With at least 4 major powerblocks/settings, it could be a wonderful "New Era" wwithout virus: The Solomani, The "Central 3I" (Dulinor, Strephon and Lucan's areas, about 2.5 domains), The Ziru Sirkaa (Restored Vilani Empire - about 1 domain), and the Domain of Deneb. Plus whatever happens in Antares and Gateway.
T4, was, acording to MWM, effectively "TNE sans Virus".
------------------
-aramis
=============================================
Smith & Wesson: The Original Point and Click interface!