• Welcome to the new COTI server. We've moved the Citizens to a new server. Please let us know in the COTI Website issue forum if you find any problems.
  • We, the systems administration staff, apologize for this unexpected outage of the boards. We have resolved the root cause of the problem and there should be no further disruptions.

Big Rocks from Space!

Whoa, that's a worry...


If a 3km rock hits Newcastle (30k's away)...i'm going to get sucked into a lava filled crater...after I've been blinded by a fire ball probably visible from orbit...EEK!

(btw - for kinetic weapons effects, RAND corporation did a document called 'Space Weapons, Earth Wars' where they go into reasonable detail about cost/effectiveness of a variety of orbital launch/bombardment weapons.

http://www.rand.org/publications/MR/MR1209/

D/L it free as a pdf. Didja know the USSR actually DID do an orbital bombardment test?)
 
50m 72 kps ferrous comes diving in to anchorage, My trailer gets tossed by the wind gust... and if it's striaght down, it'll wipe out a goodly sized part of downtown...

Even a 30m rock could result in big property damage....

Hideous calculator... I love it!
 
Originally posted by malek77:
If a 3km rock hits Newcastle (30k's away)...i'm going to get sucked into a lava filled crater...after I've been blinded by a fire ball probably visible from orbit...EEK!
If it hit Newcastle I'd be ...
toast.gif
 
Something similar to this helped me out once - someone asked me if one of those really big asteroids would hit, and this allowed me to say that it's much less likely now than 3 billion years ago. Unless there's something coming from out-system!

Thanks for finding this, though.
 
It is much less likely that we're hit by a really big asteroid now than it was several billion years ago. In the early days of the solar system, while the planets were forming, there were many more asteroids flying around (makes sense, given that this is how planets form and grow - by accreting lots of planetesimals). So you start off with lots and lots of small bodies, and then towards the end of the process, you're left with fewer small bodies and some large ones. One of the large (Mars-sized) objects hit Earth a glancing blow about 4 billion years ago and the Moon formed as a result of that.

So the impact rate was high about 4 billion years ago - even after the planets formed, there was a lot of debris still flying around - but eventually most of the big and small bodies in the planet-crossing orbits would have either hit the planets or been flung out of the system or into "safe" orbits. So the impact rate dropped, and has been very slowly dropping ever since. But the risk is always there - after all, we got nailed by a small (km-sized) rock about 65 million years which wiped out the dinosaurs and much of the rest of life on Earth.

In more recent years, in 1908 we got hit by a very small rocky object that blew up in the sky over Tunguska, Siberia with the force of a small nuke. In 1994, we saw a comet broken into many pieces and hit Jupiter - if that happened on Earth, we wouldn't have a chance. The risk of impact is still very real - but governments don't seem to want to do much about it. While it is very unlikely, fact is, if it does happen we're toast. It just takes one smallish rock to hit Earth to end civilisation.
 
Back
Top